Butternut Squash Mac and Cheese

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please see my Privacy Policy for more details.

The PERFECT vegan mac and cheese! You will not believe how good this is!!! No soy, fake cheese or nutritional yeast. Made with real whole food ingredients, this Butternut Squash Mac and Cheese will become a regular on your dinner table!

**This recipe was featured on CBS’ The Doctors tv show. Watch me talk about the recipe with Dr. Travis and see the results of a LIVE kids taste test here!**

The only vegan mac and cheese recipe you’ll ever need!

It’s made with 100% whole food ingredients – No soy. No processed cheese. No oil. No nutritional yeast.

Just good for you healthy food!

The kids love it. Husband, family, friends, and neighbors…they all love it.!

Pleasing vegans, omnivores, adults, and kids alike, this Butternut Squash Mac and Cheese is one creamy pasta dish you don’t want to miss!

Ingredients you need

Ingredient notes and substitutions

Noodles ~ Elbow noodles are classic for mac and cheese, but this sauce will work with any of your favorite noodle shapes. Small shells, penne, and rotini are our other faves for this dish.

Use gluten free noodles, if you need/want.

*Pro tip: After learning of our daughters gluten sensitivity, we have tried nearly every kind of gluten free noodle out there. Our favorite is by far the Tinkyada noodles! They stay al dente, they don’t clump up, my kids can’t tell the difference between these and regular pasta, and its made from just organic brown rice and water! Try it!

Butternut Squash ~ This healthy veggie gives us the classic golden color of mac and cheese. It’s nutty and earthy with a slight sweetness. It blends up super creamy when paired with the other ingredients.

I buy a whole one and prep it myself, but most grocery stores now sell pre-chopped butternut squash in the produce section and you can often find it frozen as well. It costs more to buy the pre-chopped kind, but it can save you time for sure. Use what you’re comfortable with.

Pumpkin or sweet potato can be used instead though both will give slight flavor variations to the final dish.

Love butternut squash? You’ll love my vegan butternut squash risotto!

Cashews ~ Raw cashews blend up silky smooth and help to give this dish its thick creamy texture.

For a nut free version, try using white beans, like cannellini or Great Northern, in place of the cashews.

Spices ~ Mustard provides a sharp, tangy kick that balances the the other flavors and helps to create a “cheesy” taste.

A clove of fresh garlic can be used instead of the garlic powder.

Smoked paprika lends a great subtle smokiness that is great paired with “cheesy” dishes.

Turmeric adds extra oomph to the bright golden color. If you don’t have it, you can leave it out.

I was always taught to add a pinch of nutmeg to creamy “white” sauces. You won’t taste it in the final dish, but it gives a little extra something to the background flavors. Again, if you don’t have it, you can leave it out.

Optional add-ins ~ For an extra “cheesy” flavor, try adding 2 tablespoons of nutritional yeast or 1 tablespoon of mellow white miso. Blend into the sauce until smooth.

How to make the recipe

Cook the noodles according to package directions. Before draining, be sure to save 1 cup of the pasta cooking liquid to add to the sauce!

To prep the butternut squash, first slice it in half lengthwise (1) and scoop out the seeds (2).

Peel the squash with a vegetable peeler or a sharp knife and chop it into cubes and slice the onion thinly (3).

Add the squash and onions along with the raw cashews to a pot and cover with water by about 1 to 2 inches (4).

Cook the squash/onion/cashew mixture until the squash is tender. Pierce a piece with a fork or knife (5). If it slides in easily, it’s done. Drain (6).

Add the veggies and cashews to a blender along with the remaining ingredients (7). Blend until perfectly smooth (8).

Stir the sauce into the cooked noodles and serve!

Storage/Freezing

The sauce mixed with the noodles will keep in the fridge for several days. You will need to add a bit more liquid – plain, unsweetened almond or oat milk works well – when reheating.

You can also freeze the mac and cheese, but please note that the noodles will likely be a tad soft when thawing/reheating.

The sauce by itself is great for prepping ahead. It will keep in the fridge in an air-tight container for 4 to 5 days.

It also freezes beautifully and can be thawed/reheated without losing any of the creamy texture. Again, you may need to add a bit more liquid, however, to loosen it up as it will thicken as it sits.

Pro tips for success

*Use raw cashews. They blend up super creamy and have a mild sweet flavor that complements the other flavors of the butternut squash mac and cheese. Roasted salted cashews will be too strong.

*Although the peel of butternut squash is edible, peel it! The end result will be much creamier without the peel.

*To save time, feel free to use pre-chopped butternut squash found in the produce section of the grocery store. Frozen chopped squash can also be used.

*Don’t forget to save ½ cup of the pasta cooking liquid before draining the noodles! The starch in the water helps create the silky creamy texture.

*Use a high speed blender to ensure the sauce blends up silky smooth.

*If you are making this sauce on it’s own without the noodles, you can use water, unsweetened plain non-dairy milk, or the cooking liquid from the squash/onions in place of the pasta cooking water.

*For an extra “cheesy” flavor, try adding 1 tablespoon of mellow white miso (note: contains soy) or 2 tablespoons of nutritional yeast. Blend into the sauce until smooth.

*To make this nut free, use white beans (cannelllini or Great Northern) instead of cashews.

*This sauce is already gluten free. To make the final dish gluten free, choose gluten free noodles.

*This dreamy butternut squash mac and cheese sauce is so versatile. Try serving it over baked potatoes or steamed broccoli, use it as a dip for tortilla chips or french fries, or stir it into soups or chilis.

FAQs

More vegan pasta recipes

• One Pot Hummus Pasta
• Vegan Cincinnati Chili
• Creamy Vegan Mushroom Pasta
• Creamy Lemon Ziti
• Vegan Spinach Artichoke Pasta

I hope you love this recipe as much as we do! If you tried it, please use the rating system in the recipe card and leave a comment below with your feedback.

Be sure to sign up for my FREE Newsletter to be the first to get my NEW recipes! You can also follow me on Instagram, Facebook, and Pinterest.

For even more easy family recipes, be sure to check out my cookbook, The Meatless Monday Family Cookbook!